Peer Review Policy

The International Journal of Engineering, Science and Humanities (IJESH) follows a double-blind peer review process to ensure the highest standards of academic quality, integrity, and objectivity. Both the reviewer and the author remain anonymous throughout the review process to maintain fairness and impartiality.

Review Process

  1. Initial Screening – All submitted manuscripts are first evaluated by the editorial team for originality, relevance, formatting, and compliance with the journal’s scope. Submissions not meeting these criteria may be rejected without external review.
  2. Peer Review – Manuscripts passing the initial screening are sent to at least two independent experts in the relevant field for evaluation. Reviewers assess the paper’s originality, clarity, methodological rigor, significance, and contribution to existing knowledge.
  3. Decision – Based on reviewers’ feedback, the editor may recommend:
    • Acceptance
    • Minor revision
    • Major revision
    • Rejection
  4. Revisions – Authors are required to revise their manuscripts as per reviewer comments and resubmit within the given timeframe. Revised submissions may be re-evaluated by the reviewers.
  5. Final Decision – The Editor-in-Chief makes the final decision regarding acceptance, ensuring that all reviews are considered fairly.

Reviewer Responsibilities

  • Maintain confidentiality of manuscripts.
  • Provide objective, constructive, and timely feedback.
  • Disclose any potential conflicts of interest.

Author Responsibilities

  • Ensure originality and ethical compliance of their work.
  • Address reviewer comments carefully and transparently.
  • Avoid submitting the same manuscript to multiple journals simultaneously.

Reviewer Spotlight & Editorial Feature: Advancing Excellence in Engineering, Science and Humanities Research

At International Journal of Engineering, Science and Humanities, the strength of our publication lies not only in the quality of submissions we receive but also in the rigor, integrity and dedication of our peer reviewers. Behind every published article is a process shaped by thoughtful evaluation, constructive critique and a shared commitment to advancing knowledge.

In this feature, we are proud to recognize our outstanding reviewers Dr. Mukesh Kumar, Dr. Sandeep Kumar, Dr. Abhijit Kelkar, Dr. Shyam Bihari Goyal, Dr. Parwinder Kaur and Mr. Utsav Malankiya whose contributions have consistently elevated the standards of our journal.

With a strong academic and professional foundation our editorial team members brings expertise in engineering, science and humanities research. Peer review is often perceived as a gatekeeping function. However, exceptional reviewers transform it into a collaborative process and this is where they stands out.

Their reviews consistently demonstrate:

  • Structured and methodical evaluation of manuscripts
  • Identification of strengths and critical gaps in methodology
  • Clear, actionable recommendations for improvement
  • Balanced feedback that supports rigor and innovation

Rather than limiting their role to assessment, they actively contributes in a core team to improving the quality, clarity and impact of the research he reviews.

In today’s fast-paced academic environment, maintaining both speed and quality in peer review is essential.

Over last several years, they have demonstrated exceptional reliability in balancing between efficiency and rigor ensures that high-quality research reaches the community without unnecessary delays. Beyond individual reviews, they reflects a broader understanding of the role peer reviewers play in shaping scientific progress. Their approach highlights that peer review is not just evaluation but it is a meaningful contribution to the growth and refinement of knowledge.

The contributions of dedicated reviewers like them directly influence the credibility and impact of International Journal of Engineering, Science and Humanities. Their work reinforces our core values of integrity in research, fair and unbiased evaluation and continuous improvement of scholarly work.

The editorial board extends its sincere appreciation to the members of editorial team for their continued dedication, professionalism and invaluable contributions. Reviewers of this caliber are essential to sustaining the quality and reputation of peer-reviewed publishing. We are honored to have them as part of our reviewer community and look forward to their continued involvement in advancing engineering, science and humanities research.

Commitment to Integrity

IJESH is committed to upholding the ethical standards of scholarly publishing. Any instances of plagiarism, unethical research, or data falsification will result in rejection or retraction of the manuscript.